Training isn’t a substitute for good design

Training isn't a band-aid for bad design

Training isn’t the only—and often isn’t the best—risk mitigation strategy.

I teach Human-Systems Integration for Modeling and Simulation (HSI for M&S) at the local university. In one of the assignments, students are asked to identify five risks in a hypothetical system development project. After identifying the risks, they have to plan prevention and minimization strategies for each.

This is a pretty straightforward risk management assignment; the only somewhat unique feature is that all of the risks must involve humans in some way. Examples might include operator errors due to poor usability or lack of sufficient staff due to unsupportable manpower requirements.

Despite the wide array of “human-centric” risks that the students might select—and correspondingly broad range of prevention and mitigation strategies—I keep seeing the same risk management solution appear: Training.

Bad usability? We’ll train the operators to be more careful.

Cybersecurity concerns? We’ll provide training to make the users more aware.

Manpower issues? We’ll train our workforce to make them more productive.

I may be seeing these plans from my graduate students, but I’m sure that similar thoughts have gone through real-world system designers’ minds. It seems commonplace to see training used as a band-aid to fix system design issues that should have been prevented sometime earlier in the system’s lifecycle.

Why isn’t training the (only) answer?

Training is good, but it shouldn’t be the whole risk management strategy, and it certainly shouldn’t be listed as the main risk mitigation approach for most system design issues. Too often, I’ve seen groups adopt the idea that “training is a solution for all problems,” which is an issue for several reasons:

First, training is (essentially) the last opportunity for solving systems-level problems/risks. Before reaching the training stage, system developers have the opportunity to build many other safeguards or improved design features into the system. More often than not, these built-in, designed components more effectively and efficiently address system issues (versus trying to train the personnel to work around system issues). For example, if a computer interface has a poorly human-factored Graphical User Interface (GUI), the system developers could spend money upfront to improve the design, or they could implement training (downstream) to help operators learn to use the non-intuitive interface—and incur repeated training costs, achieve lower effectiveness, and probably frustrate the operators in the process.

Second, another caution about focusing too myopically on training is that this can reinforce the “blame the operator” culture. Although most errors require some incident at the “acute” (or “tactical” or “on-the-ground”) operator/system interface, that doesn’t mean that operator errors are the primary cause of most system failures. As James Reason’s well-known “Swiss Cheese” model of system failure shows, system failures require multiple “holes” to line-up, and both acute and latent issues are needed to cause a failure. Training generally only affects the acute errors; additional strategies are needed to mitigate the other latent “holes” within the system.

Third and finally, training is not a magic bullet. Think about all of the training courses you’ve experienced. How effective were most of them? And did they help you have consistently perfect performance once you completed them? It’s difficult and expensive to reliably and effectively train a workforce, and it’s unreasonable to expect humans to consistently perform without any error. So, while training is important, it shouldn’t be the sole defense against risks—particularly if system design features, implemented earlier in the system lifecycle, could more effectively and affordably manage those risks.

23 Comments

  1. 2 May 2020    

    Muchas gracias. ?Como puedo iniciar sesion?

  2. 4 May 2020    

    Muchas gracias. ?Como puedo iniciar sesion?

  3. 19 June 2020    

    Hello there, There’s no doubt that your site might be having browser compatibility problems.
    Whenever I look at your site in Safari, it looks
    fine however, if opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping issues.
    I simply wanted to provide you with a quick heads up!
    Aside from that, great blog!

  4. 20 June 2020    

    Aw, this was an extremely good post. Spending some
    time and actual effort to produce a top notch article… but what
    can I say… I procrastinate a lot and never seem to get anything done.

  5. 21 June 2020    

    If some one wants to be updated with most recent technologies
    then he must be pay a visit this website and be up to date all the time.

  6. Jerrymiz's Gravatar Jerrymiz
    21 June 2020    

    Знаете ли вы?
    Не удержавшись от писательства, Амалия Кахана-Кармон создала одну из важнейших книг в истории Израиля.
    Первый футбольный трофей после начала пандемии коронавируса был разыгран в Таджикистане.
    Врач на карантине спел созданную для фильма песню Высоцкого «Давно смолкли залпы орудий».
    Член Зала хоккейной славы готов был играть где угодно, лишь бы не переходить в тренеры.
    100-летний ветеран внёс уникальный вклад в борьбу со смертельной угрозой.

    arbeca

  7. Jerrymiz's Gravatar Jerrymiz
    21 June 2020    

    Знаете ли вы?
    Копенгагенский собор пришлось выстроить заново после визита англичан в 1807 году.
    Первый в мире короткоствольный револьвер (англ.)русск. с откидным барабаном стал символом кинонуара.
    Американский лейтенант из конвоя PQ-17 был спасён советским танкером и наладил его оборону от авианалётов.
    Хотя ареал белизского геккона состоит из нескольких крохотных островов, IUCN не считает его раздробленным.
    Один из старейших музеев Амстердама находится в церкви на чердаке.

    http://arbeca.net

  8. 21 June 2020    

    Hey there! This is kind of off topic but I need some help from an established blog.
    Is it very difficult to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I
    can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about creating my own but
    I’m not sure where to start. Do you have any ideas or
    suggestions? Many thanks

  9. 25 June 2020    

    Very good write-up. I definitely appreciate this website.

    Stick with it!

  10. 26 June 2020    

    If you want to increase your know-how simply keep
    visiting this site and be updated with the hottest information posted here.

  11. 26 June 2020    

    whoah this weblog is excellent i like reading your articles.
    Keep up the great work! You know, lots of persons are looking around for this
    information, you could aid them greatly.

  12. 26 June 2020    

    Hello There. I found your blog the use of msn. This is
    an extremely smartly written article. I will make sure to bookmark
    it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for
    the post. I’ll definitely return.

  13. 26 June 2020    

    Hello mates, how is everything, and what you would like to say about this paragraph, in my view its genuinely awesome in support of me.

  14. 27 June 2020    

    There’s definately a great deal to know about this topic.

    I love all of the points you made.

  15. 27 June 2020    

    Hello to every body, it’s my first pay a visit of this blog; this website
    consists of remarkable and genuinely good material in support of readers.

  16. 27 June 2020    

    I think that is one of the such a lot significant information for me.
    And i am happy reading your article. However should observation on some normal things, The web site style
    is wonderful, the articles is really excellent : D.
    Excellent task, cheers

  17. 27 June 2020    

    Hello, I enjoy reading all of your post. I wanted to write a little comment to
    support you.

  18. 28 June 2020    

    I could not refrain from commenting. Perfectly written!

  19. 28 June 2020    

    Great weblog here! Also your web site so much up fast!
    What web host are you using? Can I get your associate hyperlink
    in your host? I want my site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  20. 9 July 2020    

    Like!! I blog frequently and I really thank you for your content. The article has truly peaked my interest.

  21. I learn something new and challenging on blogs I stumbleupon everyday.

  22. Thanks for fantastic info I was looking for this info for my mission.

  23. SMS's Gravatar SMS
    9 July 2020    

    Very good article! We are linking to this particularly great content on our site. Keep up the great writing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *